<img height="1" width="1" style="display:none;" alt="" src="https://dc.ads.linkedin.com/collect/?pid=200498&amp;fmt=gif">
Toggle Nav

Puritan Blog

Dec 12, 2014Print this page

Why Flocked Swabs Should Not be Coated

Why_You_Sould_Never_Coat_Flocked_Swabs

Flocked swabs have been hailed by the microbiology and diagnostic communities for their ability to absorb and elute more specimen than traditional fiber or foam swabs. But not all flocked swabs are created equal. 

Some flocked swabs, like Copan's eSwab, are coated with biopolymers that are said to “improve the recovery and survival of organisms.”

However, a recent study published in the Indian Journal of Medical Microbiology has concluded that coating flocked swab tips does “not uniformly demonstrate higher recovery compared with their uncoated counterparts.”1

Additionally, there is evidence that protein solubilization from the swab-tip may affect the storage viability of the samples collected.

In a 2012 letter to the editor published in the Journal of Clinical Virology, Christophe Indevuyst of the Laboratory Medicine at University Hospitals Leuven in Belgium hypothesizes that "the pretreatment of [Copan’s eSwab flocked swab] with a vegetal protein…has a toxic effect on cell cultures."2

Here’s more information on the study published in the Indian Journal of Medical Microbiology: 

Coated Flocked Swab Study Objective

The goal of this study was to address the assertion that coating swab heads with biopolymers such as protein improves the recovery and survival of organisms, and “to assess the effect of swab head material coating, water absorption capacity and capture and release characteristics of four pathogenic bacteria from protein coated and uncoated flocked swabs."

Swabs Tested

Research Method

The researchers obtained test organisms and performed water absorption tests on whole swabs (five of each type), separated swab fibers (five samples for each type) and the culture studies to evaluate the collection and release of bacteria. Twelve swabs of each swab type were used for culture studies and each organism was cultured in triplicate.

Study Results

The researchers found that protein coating of swab tips did not uniformly demonstrate higher recovery compared with their uncoated counterparts. The researchers also note that the “higher water absorption of swab tip fibres of uncoated HydraFlock® that potentially prevents desiccation of microbes, coupled with overall superior collection and release of test bacteria among test swabs, is likely to be the choice for clinical diagnostics.”

Choose Puritan's Uncoated Flocked Swabs

Puritan’s HydraFlock® flocked swab absorption capacity is dictated by the high-quality fibers and proprietary flocking method we employ. We don’t need to coat our swab tips (and potentially compromise sample viability) because our swabs are absorbent enough on their own. 

To learn more about what makes Puritan flocked swabs the superior choice for microbiologists and diagnosticians, click below to speak with one of our knowledgable product specialists. 

Swab-Specialist-Puritan

SOURCES: 

1.Harry KH, Madhusudhan KT. Effect of protein coating of locked swabs on the collection and release of clinically important bacteria. Indian J Med Microbiology 2014;32:301-3. Retrieved December 8, 2014 from: http://www.puritanmedproducts.com/assets/uploads/general/Effect_of_protein_coating_of_flocked_swabs_on_the_collection_and_release_of_clinically_important_bacteria-1.pdf

2.eSwab flocked swabs unfit for viral culture. Journal of Clinical Virology 55 (2012) 282–283. [Article access purchased from http://www.journalofclinicalvirology.com/article/S1386-6532(12)00259-4/abstract December 11, 2014] 

Topics: Flocked Swabs, Diagnostics, Scientific Studies

Comments

How To Videos

Visit our training center, where you can view videos on a range of applications from food safety to microbiology.


Videos

Resource Library

We've compiled our content in a handy library so you can find all our best resources in one place.


Resource Library

Find a Distributor

Using our distributor chart, you can see a list of distributors where you can buy our products.


Where to Buy

Recent Posts

Posts Archive

More Archives

Subscribe


Stay informed about industry news, current events, and the unique properties of Puritan's wide range of products that set them apart from the rest.

Copyright © 2022 Puritan Medical Products. All rights reserved.Proudly Made in the USA