<img height="1" width="1" style="display:none;" alt="" src="https://dc.ads.linkedin.com/collect/?pid=200498&amp;fmt=gif">
Toggle Nav

Puritan Blog

Sep 23, 2020Print this page

Is it COVID-19 or the Flu? A New Study Provides Insight

COVID-19 or the FluWith flu season swiftly approaching, one of the many challenges practitioners will soon be grappling with is whether a symptomatic patient is likely to have COVID or the flu. A recent study provides a few clues that may help with diagnosis.

Why this is valuable information

There’s a lot of overlap between flu symptoms and those associated with COVID-19. Common signs associated with both illnesses include fever, cough and fatigue. Patients with either virus may also report less-common symptoms such as muscle aches, gastrointestinal upset, congestion, sore throat, runny nose, loss of smell and headache.

While testing is the only way to rule in or rule out influenza virus or SARS-CoV-2, this study found that the order of symptom occurrence may provide insight into a potential diagnosis. Early indicators can help identify which patients to test quickly and provide useful guidance around taking precautions such as quarantining if COVID-19 is suspected. This is particularly important given that COVID-19 is two to three times more contagious than influenza.

Which came first: Cough or fever?

Researchers at the University of Southern California modeled and analyzed data from thousands of patients worldwide who were diagnosed with COVID-19, influenza, SARS (severe acute respiratory syndrome) and MERS (Middle Eastern respiratory syndrome). Their analysis showed that a cough is most likely the first symptom of the flu. In contrast, a fever is most often the first symptom of COVID-19 as well as SARS and MERS. 

Study methodology

Published in the Frontiers in Public Health, researchers applied a Markov Process to a graded, partially ordered set based on clinical observation of COVID-19 cases to determine the most likely order of noticeable symptoms. These were then compared to the progression of symptoms for influenza, SARS and MERS to see if the diseases presented differently. Data from over 55,000 patients worldwide was used for the study.

Additional findings

Another interesting observation was that the upper GI tract tended to be affected before the lower GI tract in COVID-19 cases; the inverse was true for MERS and SARS cases. A very small percentage of COVID-19 patients experienced diarrhea as an initial symptom. However, each of these patients went on to eventually have pneumonia or respiratory failure, which researchers hypothesize meant they had a more aggressive form of COVID-19. This could also be helpful information for clinicians to keep in mind, though more research is needed to support this theory. 

What it could mean

The researchers recommend that practitioners record the order of symptom occurrence for COVID-19 and other diseases. When medical professionals have clues that can help them discern differences in common symptoms, such as the order of occurrence and likely first symptoms, it can help with early detection of COVID-19 and future diseases. This could ultimately go a long way to help reduce the spread of outbreaks and could even contain them before they become epidemics or pandemics. 

For on coronavirus, check out our COVID-19 portal with lots of handy tools and resources. Or get the latest news and information when you sign up for our newsletter.

Topics: Flu, Environmental and Food Safety, COVID-19


How To Videos

Visit our training center, where you can view videos on a range of applications from food safety to microbiology.


Resource Library

We've compiled our content in a handy library so you can find all our best resources in one place.

Resource Library

Find a Distributor

Using our distributor chart, you can see a list of distributors where you can buy our products.

Where to Buy

Recent Posts

Posts Archive

More Archives


Stay informed about industry news, current events, and the unique properties of Puritan's wide range of products that set them apart from the rest.

Copyright © 2022 Puritan Medical Products. All rights reserved.Proudly Made in the USA